City of Oakland
contact the city  |   home
Forest Photograph
Living
Business Visiting City Hall

 


ceda-header location-planning

AGENDA LANDMARKS PRESERVATION

ADVISORY BOARD

OAKLAND, CA 94612

LANDMARKS PRESERVATION October 18, 2004 Regular Meeting
4 PM City Hall
6th Floor Conference Room
and Hearing Room One
One Frank Ogawa Plaza
Oakland, California 94612

ADVISORY BOARD MEMBERS:

Una M. Gilmartin, Chair

Barbara Armstrong, Vice Chair

Alan Dreyfuss

Kelley Kahn

Pamela Kershaw

Yui Hay Lee

Neal Parish

::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::

The Landmarks Board welcomes public comment on all agenda items. The Board requests that speakers limit their comments to no more than three minutes. Correspondence received by the Monday prior to the meeting date will be included in the Board’s agenda packet. (See address below.)

CLOSED SESSION

City Attorney’s Conference Room, 6th Floor

City Hall, One Frank H. Ogawa Plaza

Conference with its City Attorney pursuant to California Government Code Section 54956.9(b)(1) regarding anticipated litigation in one (1) matter.

(UPON CONCLUSION OF THE CLOSED SESSION, THE BOARD WILL RECONVENE IN OPEN SESSION IN HEARING ROOM ONE.)

ROLL CALL

OPEN FORUM

APPROVAL OF MINUTES of August 9, 2004 and

Special Meeting - September 20, 2004

OLD BUSINESS - Action Items

1.

Location:

Sheffield Village: All properties located on Roxbury Avenue, Marlow Drive, Middleton Street, Covington Street, Brookfield Avenue, Danbury Street properties from 2900 to 3200 inclusive, Revere Avenue and 11810 to 11848 Foothill Blvd.

Proposal:

Landmark nomination

 

Recommendation:

LPAB Action to Adopt Resolution Initiating Landmark Designation and direct staff to forward the nomination to the Planning Commission for public hearing on the proposed designation.

Owner/Applicant:

Sheffield Village Homeowners Association (Christopher L. Barker)

General Plan:

Detached Unit Residential

Zoning:

R-30

Environmental Determination:

Exempt per Sections 15061(3) and 15331 of the State CEQA Guidelines.

Historic Status:

Oakland Cultural Heritage Survey Preliminary Rating – Area of Secondary Importance

Service Delivery District:

East Oakland 6

City Council District:

7

For Further Information

Contact Betty Marvin (510) 238-6879, bmarvin@oaklandnet.com

2.

Location:

8945 Golf Links Road – Holy Redeemer Center

Proposal:

  1. Board Reconsideration of Motion to Deny Holy Redeemer Center Counsel’s request to extend time limit for response of owner comments on provisional designation as a Heritage Property;
  2. Reconsideration of request from owner’s counsel to LPAB to extend time limit for response of owner comments on provisional designation as a Heritage Property;
  3. Consideration of Property owner comments;

4) Designation of Holy Redeemer Center as Heritage Property.

Recommendation:

Based on Staff Report

Owner:

Redemptorist Society of California

General Plan:

Detached Unit Residential

Zoning:

R-30

Environmental Determination:

To be determined

Historic Status:

Potential Designated Historic Property (PDHP); Preliminary Evaluation Sheet for Landmark Eligibility – "A" (LPAB Adoption of Preliminary Rating Sheet has not yet occurred.)

Service Delivery District:

East Oakland 6

City Council District:

7

For Further Information

Contact Joann Pavlinec (510) 238-6344, jpavlinec@oaklandnet.com

NEW BUSINESS - Action Items

3.

Location:

365 45th Street, Studio One Art Center

Proposal:

Design Review of exterior modifications including new entry porch addition, new window and door replacements in existing openings, new photo-voltaic solar panels, new mechanical exhaust/ventilation roof features, new door openings at rear and side, new emergency exit stair.

 

Recommendation:

LPAB Action - Recommend approval of design review, with conditions.

Owner/Applicant:

City of Oakland

General Plan:

Institutional

Zoning:

OS (SU)/S-18: Open Space-Special Use Park; Mediated Residential Design Review

Environmental Determination:

City Council approved an Addendum for the Oakland Clean Water, Safe Waterfront Parks and Recreation Trust Fund Ballot Measure in June 2002. The current project will be reviewed using this document as a basis of information. Any further documentation necessary will be provided prior to approval of final construction project.

Historic Status:

Potential Designated Historic Property; Rated B2+ on the Preservation Study List; (‘B’ – indicates Major Importance; ‘2’ – Area of Secondary Importance; ‘+’ - indicates contributor.)

Service Delivery District:

North Oakland 2

City Council District:

1

For Further Information

Contact Joann Pavlinec (510) 238-6344, jpavlinec@oaklandnet.com

4.

Location:

Wood Street Development (formerly Central Station Project), West Oakland. Approximately 29.2 acres between 10th Street to the south, West Grand Avenue to the north, Wood Street to the east, and the I-880 frontage road to the west.

APNs – various

Proposal:

Public Hearing on the Draft Environmental Impact Report to obtain comments regarding the environmental analysis related to a residential, live-work, retail, and other commercial mixed use development. The site would be redeveloped with up to 1,570 residential units, including 186 live-work units in converted warehouses. Commercial space would include 13,000 s. f. feet of neighborhood-serving commercial uses plus 14,487 s.f. associated with the historic Southern Pacific 16th Street train station. The main hall of the train station and the 16th Street signal tower would be restored. Public open space, consisting of a public plaza in front of the station’s main hall and five pocket parks totaling 1.39 acres would be provided. In addition, 2.82 acres of private open space will be created for residents. All other structures will be demolished, including the platform and baggage building.

Applicant:

Build West Oakland, LLC; PCL Associates, LLC; HFH Central Station Village, LLC; Central Station Land, LLC

Owner:

Five property owners

Case File Numbers:

ER 03-0023

Planning Permits Required:

General Plan Amendment, Zoning Code Amendment and Rezoning, Redevelopment Plan Amendment, Preliminary and Final Development Plans, Vesting Tentative Parcel Maps, Design Review, Tree Removal

General Plan:

Business Mix

Zoning:

M-20/S-16, (Light Industrial/Industrial-Residential Transition Combining Zone); M-30, (General Industrial); M-30/S-16, General Industrial/Industrial-Residential Transition Combining Zone)

Environmental Determination:

A Draft Environmental Impact Report was published for a 49-day review period (September 20, 2004 to November 8, 2004).

Historic Status:

16th Street Train Station and 16th Street Signal Tower; Rated A1+; City of Oakland Landmark; determined eligible for National Register of Historic Places. Project area also includes PDHPs at 1751 – 57 16th Street (Dc2+) and 1111 Pine Street (Cb+2+) that are parts of adjoining Areas of Secondary Importance and adjoins the Oakland Point Area of Primary Importance (determined eligible for National Register).

Service Delivery District:

West Oakland 1

City Council District:

District 3 (Nadel)

Action to be taken:

Receive public and Commission comments on the Draft Environmental Impact Report.

For further information:

Contact project planner Margaret Stanzione at (510) 238-4932 or by email at mstanzione@oaklandnet.com

ELECTION OF OFFICERS

  • Election of Landmarks Preservation Advisory Board Chair and Vice-Chair for 2004-2005

BOARD REPORTS

  • Status of Arbor Villa Palm Trees – West side of 9th Avenue from East 24th to East 28th Streets, along Bayview Ave. from East 28th to 927 Bayview and on East 28th Street from Park Blvd. to 9th Avenue (Landmark 77-573) - Dreyfuss

ANNOUNCEMENTS

SECRETARY REPORTS

    • Review of 2005 Landmarks Preservation Advisory Board Proposed Schedule
    • Selection of Date for Secretary of Interior Standards Workshop
    • Status Report on the Camron-Stanford House, 1418 Lakeside Drive, restoration/rehabilitation
    • Informational Report on the National Trust for Historic Preservation Conference 2004

ADJOURNMENT

 

 

JOANN PAVLINEC

Secretary

NEXT REGULAR MEETING: November 8, 2004

Written correspondence should be addressed to:

Landmarks Preservation Advisory Board

250 Frank H. Ogawa Plaza, Suite 3315

Oakland, CA 94612

Fax Number: 510-238-6538

_____________________________________________________________________

This meeting is wheelchair accessible. To request materials in alternative formats, or to request an ASL interpreter, or assistive listening devise, please call Joann Pavlinec at 510-238-6344 or TDD 510-238-3254 at least three working days before the meeting. Please refrain from wearing scented products to this meeting so attendees who may experience chemical sensitivities may attend. Thank you.